The responsibility for replacing a broken toilet seat can vary depending on the terms of the lease agreement and local landlord-tenant laws. In general, maintenance and repair responsibilities between landlords and tenants are determined by the lease agreement and relevant state or local laws.
In many cases, minor repairs and maintenance tasks, like replacing a toilet seat, are typically the responsibility of the tenant. These tasks are considered part of the tenant's responsibility to maintain the property in good condition during their tenancy.
However, if the broken toilet seat is a result of normal wear and tear or a pre-existing issue, it might be the landlord's responsibility to replace it. Landlord-tenant laws often require landlords to maintain the property in a habitable condition, and this includes ensuring that essential fixtures, like toilets, are in proper working order.
If a tenant believes that the landlord should be responsible for replacing the broken toilet seat due to a pre-existing issue or negligence on the landlord's part, they should communicate the problem to the landlord or property management in writing and request the necessary repairs.
To determine the specific responsibilities in a given situation, it's crucial to review the lease agreement and become familiar with the applicable local landlord-tenant laws. If there is any confusion or dispute about who is responsible for the repair, seeking legal advice or mediation may be necessary.